Body Lotion vs Body Cream vs Body Oil: Which One You Need

Body Lotion vs Body Cream vs Body Oil: Which One You Need

Body lotion, body cream and body oil - all three moisturize, but in different ways. If your skin feels tight an hour after the shower, or your lotion seems to vanish before you have finished getting dressed, the texture you choose is usually the reason. The fix is simple: match the formula to your skin and the season.

Coming up: the real difference between body lotion vs body cream, what body oil does that lotion can’t, a comparison table, how to use body oil, cream and lotion.

Short on time? Here is the quick answer. Body lotion contains a high proportion of water and absorbs quickly. It suits normal skin and warm months. Body cream contains more butters, oils, and waxes and, as a result, it has a thicker texture. It stays on dry skin longer than lotion, especially in cold weather. Body oil contains no water. It traps the water already on your skin. Use it right after you shower. If your skin is dry in the winter, apply the oil first, then the lotion.

What is the difference between lotion vs cream?

Every moisturizer is a blend of water and oil, held together by an emulsifier. The ratio determines the texture. Lotions carry more water. They pour from a pump and spread thin. Creams contain more oils, butters, and waxes, so they stay in the jar and hold their shape on your fingertip.

Both rely on two groups of ingredients. Humectants such as glycerin and aloe draw water to the skin. Emollients, like shea butter, beeswax, and plant oils, soften the surface and slow water loss. When comparing body lotion and body cream, the cream just has more of the second group.

You can see it on our labels. Red Flower softening lotion blends shea butter, olive fruit oil, and sweet almond oil with glycerin and aloe for a lighter feel in the morning. Arctic Berry Cloud Milk Cream combines beeswax, coconut oil, apricot oil, avocado oil, cloudberry seed oil, jojoba, and honey. We make it in small batches. The cream is thicker than the lotion but absorbs fast. It works on both face and body.

Body oil vs lotion: what does oil do that lotion can’t?

Body oil doesn't contain water; therefore, it won't add hydration on its own. Instead, it holds in the water your skin already has. Apply oil over damp skin, and you get a thin, flexible layer of moisture from your shower under the oil. That is why oil feels soothing on dry skin in January, yet heavy on a humid August afternoon.

Lotion handles both jobs in one step: water to hydrate, oils to soften. However, its lighter oil content wears off faster. So, the body oil vs lotion question often ends with a simple answer: use both.

Red Flower Aromatherapeutic Body Oils are made with avocado oil, safflower seed oil, and sweet almond oil, which are rich in vitamin E and fatty acids. Each scent uses different essential oils. The ocean blend uses eucalyptus, copaiba, clove, cardamom, and laurel leaf. If you are not comfortable with fragrances, choose the unscented version.

Lotion vs cream vs oil: comparison table


Texture

Water to oil

When to use

Red Flower pick

Body lotion

Light and pourable; sinks in within a minute or two

Mostly water, with lighter oils

Mornings, warm weather, normal or slightly dry skin

Softening lotion

Body cream

Thick; holds its shape in the jar

Closer to an even mix of water and oils, butters and waxes

Evenings, cold months, dry or mature skin, rough spots

Arctic berry cloud milk cream

Body oil

Liquid and silky

No water; plant oils only

On damp skin right after the shower, in the bath, for massage

Aromatherapeutic body oil

Ratios vary by formula.

Body cream, lotion or oil: which do you need?

  • Normal skin, or a humid summer: lotion. It goes on fast, and you can dress right away.

  • Dry or mature skin, or the months the heating runs: cream, or oil under lotion.

  • Rough elbows, knees and heels: a small amount of cream worked into those spots at night.

  • Sensitive skin: the shortest ingredient list you can find, or unscented body oil. Patch test on the inside of your elbow first.

Indoor heating dries the air, and your skin follows. If lotion felt okay in September but not now, switch to cream or put a few drops of oil under the lotion.

How to use body oil

Apply body oil when your skin is warm and damp. Here is how to use body oil after a shower:

  1. Keep the shower short and warm. The American Academy of Dermatology recommends 5 to 10 minutes in warm water, since hot water dries out the skin.

  2. Pat yourself dry. Leave skin slightly moist.

  3. Warm the oil in your palms. Begin with 3-5 drops on each arm, then add a few more drops on each leg. For a slower ritual, place the bottle in a bowl of hot water for a few minutes beforehand.

  4. Massage upward. Start at your feet and work in small circles towards your heart o warm the skin.

  5. Wait 2-3 minutes before getting dressed.

You can also use body oil in other ways. For a softening soak, add approximately 20 drops to a warm bath. Add a few drops to your lotion for a one-step finish. Or keep a bottle by the bed for hand and foot massage - our massage remedy can help.

When to apply body oil

The best time to apply body oil is within a few minutes of a shower or bath, while your skin is still warm and damp. Dermatologists at the AAD recommend moisturizing immediately after pat-drying so the product seals in water from the shower. Even if you apply oil to dry skin, it will still soften it; however, there will be less moisture for the oil to hold.

  • Morning: a light layer, a few drops on the limbs. Wait a couple of minutes before getting dressed.

  • Night: a fuller layer of oil, followed by cream on dry spots.

  • Before or after lotion? Oil first on damp skin, then lotion on top. If you want it the other way around, apply lotion, then add a few drops of oil to the driest areas.

  • After spending a day outside: a few drops on arms and legs after rinsing off sun, wind, or cold.

The art of layering

At Red Flower, the last step in a bath ritual is moisturizing. The Japan shower ritual, inspired by the onsen baths of Japan, ends with oil and lotion blended into warm skin to stimulate blood circulation. A simple version takes only three minutes:

  1. Wash with a Red Flower Purifying Body Wash.

  2. Apply body oil while you are still damp.

  3. Finish with Softening Lotion, or a little Arctic Berry Cloud Milk Cream on dry spots.

For more on that first step, read how to choose a natural body wash for dry or sensitive skin.

Frequently asked questions

Can I use body oil and lotion together? 

Yes. Apply oil to damp skin first, then lotion on top. The oil holds in water, while the lotion adds hydration with a softer, less slick finish.

Which is better for dry skin, body cream or lotion?

Usually cream. It contains more butters and oils. The AAD recommends a cream or ointment for very dry skin.

When should I apply body oil?

Apply it immediately after you shower or bathe, while your skin is still damp.

Can I put body oil on my face?

Our body oils are made for body skin. For your face, choose a formula made for it from our face collection.

Lotion, cream or oil: the short version.

Use body lotion for light, everyday moisturizing. Pick a body cream for dry skin and winter. Use body oil within a few minutes of the shower to seal in water, and layer it under lotion when your skin needs both. Find your texture and scent among Red Flower lotions & creams and mists, oils & serums.

 

Previous post